
Sawmill Creek
Best for travelers who want a resort experience with on-site golf, larger meeting/wedding spaces, and easy access to Sheldon Marsh and nearby Lake Erie activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Sawmill Creek is a family-friendly lakeside resort in Huron with golf, meeting space, two pools, and nature-preserve access; this guide is for travelers who want a resort experience near Lake Erie. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island is a nationally branded, all-ages hotel near Port Clinton and Catawba Island; read on if you prefer predictable chain amenities and a short drive to island ferries.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a resort experience with on-site golf, larger meeting/wedding spaces, and easy access to Sheldon Marsh and nearby Lake Erie activities.

Best for travelers wanting a nationally branded hotel with free buffet breakfast, straightforward meeting space, and an indoor pool in the Port Clinton / Catawba Island area.
When Sawmill Creek wins: choose Sawmill Creek if you want resort amenities — an 18-hole Tom Fazio golf course, larger on-site dining and multiple bars, two pools (indoor + seasonal outdoor), outdoor nature access to Sheldon Marsh, and extensive event/wedding facilities.
When Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island wins: pick the Holiday Inn Express if you want a reliable IHG-brand experience close to Port Clinton, complimentary buffet breakfast, compact conference space (1,000 sq ft), an indoor pool and hot tub, and convenient access to local island-ferry points.
Bottom line: both are practical bases for Lake Erie travel; Sawmill Creek is the choice for resort-style stays, golf, and large events, while Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island is a simpler, branded hotel option nearer Port Clinton attractions.
| Category | Sawmill Creek | Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort with golf course, multiple on-site restaurants/bars, family activities, and large event space | National chain hotel with practical rooms, free breakfast, and compact meeting facilities |
| Location | Huron, beside Sheldon Marsh State Nature Preserve and within walking distance of Lake Erie | Port Clinton/Catawba Island area, a short drive from Lake Erie and island-ferry points |
| Size (rooms) | 239 renovated guest rooms across 2 floors | 102 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family-friendly (children welcome; kids' buffet and family amenities listed) | All ages; family- and group-friendly (up to 2 children 17 and under stay free in existing bedding) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Indoor pool (year-round) and a seasonal outdoor pool plus two hot tubs; pool bar and cabanas seasonally | Indoor pool and 1 hot tub (indoor); pool hours and access published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: The Miller's Table (fine dining), Mulligan's Pub (seasonal), Creekside Market, The Pool Bar, The Hideout | No signature on-site fine-dining restaurant listed; property provides free buffet breakfast and vending/gift shop options |
| Spa / wellness | Two hot tubs and pool-side relaxation; no verifiable, named full-service spa on record | Fitness center, indoor pool and hot tub; full-service spa: Not published |
| Known for | 18-hole Tom Fazio-designed championship golf course, large meeting/wedding venues, and nature-preserve adjacency | IHG-brand consistency, complimentary buffet breakfast, accessible meeting space (1,000 sq ft) and convenient location near Port Clinton |
| Event & meeting space | Over 35,000 sq ft of flexible indoor event space and large ballrooms (Wilderness Hall, North Hall) for weddings and conferences | Conference space totaling 1,000 sq ft (93 sq m) with meeting rooms and banquet hall |
| Parking & access | Free self-parking on-site; shuttle options listed by some sources | Free self-parking on-site |
Sawmill Creek sits beside Sheldon Marsh State Nature Preserve with walking access to lakeside trails and easy drives to Huron beaches and Cedar Point.
Choose Sawmill Creek for proximity to nature, lakeside walks, and a property with expansive grounds.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island is positioned near Port Clinton attractions, island-ferry access, and Catawba Island State Park.
Pick Holiday Inn Express for a convenient base near Port Clinton and Catawba Island access.
Sawmill Creek has 239 renovated rooms and suites in multiple categories, designed for families and groups.
Sawmill Creek offers more room inventory and family-friendly room types suited to groups and events.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island has 102 guestrooms across many accessible and suite variants.
Holiday Inn Express provides a broad selection of standard and accessible room types with typical chain conveniences.
Sawmill Creek provides multiple on-site dining venues from fine dining to casual pool and grab-and-go options.
Sawmill Creek is the better choice if variety of on-site dining and evening bars matter.
Holiday Inn Express emphasizes a complimentary buffet breakfast and practical dining conveniences.
Choose the Holiday Inn Express for reliable free morning breakfast and simple on-site food options.
Sawmill Creek offers both an indoor pool year-round and a seasonal outdoor pool with pool bar, cabanas, and two hot tubs.
Sawmill Creek is set up for guests who want both year-round swimming and a summer pool scene with cabanas and a bar.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island has an indoor pool and one hot tub available to guests.
Holiday Inn Express provides a straightforward indoor-pool experience and hot tub but lacks the seasonal outdoor pool features Sawmill Creek offers.
Sawmill Creek includes a 24-hour fitness center and multiple evening bars and lounges.
Sawmill Creek provides round-the-clock fitness plus more on-site evening bar and dining options; a full spa is not clearly documented.
Holiday Inn Express has a fitness center, business center, and low-key evening options typical of the brand.
Holiday Inn Express covers basic wellness needs and business services without an on-site spa listing.

Sawmill Creek — on-site 18-hole Tom Fazio championship course and clubhouse dining.

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island — IHG standards, free breakfast, many accessible room types.

Sawmill Creek — extensive event space (over 35,000 sq ft) and large ballrooms for big groups.

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island — complimentary buffet breakfast and compact meeting space.
Sawmill Creek is explicitly family-friendly with kids’ buffet options, a children’s pool area, and family activities; the Holiday Inn Express is family-friendly too but is more of a practical chain hotel.
No verifiable, named full-service spa is published for either property; Sawmill Creek has hot tubs and pool-area relaxation features, while Holiday Inn Express lists fitness, pool and hot tub but no spa.
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Port Clinton-Catawba Island is located in Port Clinton and is closer to island-ferry activities and Catawba Island access.
Sawmill Creek — it offers far larger, more flexible event spaces and ballrooms; Holiday Inn Express has modest conference space (about 1,000 sq ft) suitable for small meetings.
Explore how Sawmill Creek stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·